The Difference Between Coaching, Consulting, and Advisory (and Why You Need All Three)

I’ve frequently had clients say things like “You’re the best coach I’ve ever had – even though you don’t call yourself a coach.” It speaks to a common confusion about practices and techniques that we associate with certain professions and what we expect them to do for us in our businesses.

In this article, I explore where the boundaries are (including why I’m not a “coach” per se), how those boundaries affect the type of support you get, and how you might actually need a blend to get the result you need.

Coach, Consultant, or Advisor: What’s the actual difference?

On the surface, it can seem like the labels coach, consultant, and advisor are used interchangeably – or perhaps even chosen randomly. I think that’s due largely to the fact that these aren’t rigid boxes, but indicators of the primary role they play in the service relationship and what they emphasize in order to perform that role. Looking at it this way, it’s natural for there to be overlap between techniques employed – and confusion over who does what.

Coaches draw out the client’s thinking

Coach tends to be the label we reach for when we want help clarifying goals, exploring and choosing between options, and accountability. While a coach might offer their own observations or suggestions, the primary emphasis is on the client’s own thinking and choices. Many times this gets described as, “The answer is inside of you” as opposed to looking for answers outside of yourself; the coach might employ exercises, frameworks, or other techniques to draw it out and crystalize it so that you work with it and move forward.

Coaching can happen 1-to-1, in a group, on an ongoing basis, or as part of a workshop or program; the format isn’t fixed.

There are organizations that certify coaches, such as the International Coaching Federation (ICF) and ICF-accredited programs, but certification isn’t necessary to call yourself a coach – or be a good one who helps clients get results.

Consultants apply specialized expertise

Consultant tends to be the label we reach for when we’re looking for someone else to come in, assess our situation, and apply their own expertise, experiences, perspectives, and frameworks to our situations – usually to a specific problem to solve. In other words, they’re the expert we’re consulting for a relatively finite period.

Consultants might be called in only to diagnose the situation and make recommendations for change, or take a more active role in implementation and adoption. The shape of the problem and their area of expertise help to define where they fit. Again, the exact format isn’t fixed; the consultant may work 1-to-1 with a client, including a designated “point person” to represent the company’s side of a project, work with many people in the company over the course of the engagement, or through offers such as workshops and programs.

Advisors offer sustained perspective and guidance

Advisory tends to be the label we reach for when looking for “wisdom” or sustained perspective and guidance. Advisors typically have experience or expertise that means that they’re qualified to give advice, and draw from their own experiences, perspectives, and frameworks to do so.

The relationship is usually 1-to-1,  but can include teams and others depending on the work to be done. This work also tends to be ongoing over a longer time period.

If coaches are helping you draw out your own thinking and consultants are applying their expertise to a specific type of problem, advisors are generally called in for “higher level” decision making and direction-related issues. Advisory Boards are a scaled-up and formally embedded version of this that you might see in some larger companies.

While the client – or, in the case of an advisory board, the top executive – still makes all the final decisions, solutions tend to be more co-constructed with an advisor than they are with a coach or consultant. When reaching for the right label, it’s not uncommon for advisors to be confused with “coaches” – or even “mentors.”

How does fractional work fit in here?

One of the more prominent labels that has emerged in business circles is that of the fractional (e.g., Fractional COO). Someone operating under this label usually embeds into the company in a different way, taking over the duties of what would otherwise be a full-time employee serving in that role. The benefit of a fractional is usually being able to tap into expertise without having to supply employee benefits, and can serve a company well at certain growth stages (i.e., before they’re ready to hire someone full time) or when the need doesn’t quite require a full-time person in that role.

But, this is important: Being a fractional is a matter of payment arrangements and access, not the primary role they play in the work. A retainer agreement with a coach, consultant, advisor – or service provider who provides some blend of these three – might have the same look-and-feel of someone you’ve engaged in a fractional way. In other words, a fractional may employ any blend of coaching, consulting, or advisory over the course of their engagement with you.

Role-shifting Can Be a Service Feature and a Strategic Advantage

When looking for a professional to help you in your business, it’s common to look in terms of “Who do I hire?” (i.e., what label they use) and “What do they do?”

Those are important questions to answer, especially when you’re looking to match your desired result against the transformational promise offered by a particular service.

But, based on what I’ve covered in this article, I’m going to ask you to push a little deeper – and look at the process of “How” the work is done.

In other words, does their mix of Coach / Consultant / Advisor match with the current state of your business – and what you need to move forward?

As an example, if you’re looking for implementation help: Do you have a project that’s ready to hand off to someone who can just perform the steps, or do you need some clarity on exactly what you want this to achieve and how to get there? In the latter case, if you’re looking for a freelancer or consultant, and they just want the scope without asking questions … they might not be the right fit for you. If it’s the former, that person who doesn’t really ask questions (beyond clarification on instructions) – and maybe can even take over the SOPs you’ve already written for this task (i.e., act as your delegate) – the freelancer who is ready to just get the work done is probably exactly what you need.

Why a Blended Approach – or a Variety of Services Offering Different Types of Support – Tends to Feel Uncomfortable

It can feel uncomfortable to step outside of the common labels and accept a mix, because, on the surface, it can look like you’re about to hire a “jack of all trades” whose breadth is too superficial to help you, or where they’re trying to be “all things to all people.”

A service provider who is able to role-shift might actually be to your strategic advantage. It can be the sign that a service provider is able to say: “I will be the mirror you need when you’re confused, uncertain, or tangled (coaching), the guide you need when you’re deciding (advisory), and the architect you need when you’re building (consulting).”

Rather than you having to find – and coordinate – different service providers for all the parts of the work that need to be done.

How Coaching, Consulting, and Advisory are Used at Blou Designs

In Blou Designs’ work, I definitely use strategic blends of all three roles in my work.

Regardless of the service provided, I incorporate some level of coaching-like techniques and practices to get to the kind of articulated clarity we need – the kind that can be acted upon (rather than just feeling like clarity and momentum in the moment, but that leaves you hanging later on).

The benefit of this clarity is twofold:

  • This is what enables us to ideate solutions that don’t just feel perfect on paper, but that fit your situation.
  • No one can control everything or predict everything that’s going to happen; “the only thing we can rely on is change.” Being really clear about context – including constraints and what you’re trying to achieve – lets us adapt (e.g., switch out tactics) as needed and build systems that are more resilient, all while keeping our “eye on the prize.”

For the actual work on operational brand, SOPs, data, and day-to-day operations, I tend to shift into a more advisory/consulting role. In this way, my clients benefit from my years of consulting across a range of companies and my other expertise, while also defining and capturing their own judgement calls into the systems we design (and sometimes implement) together.

That’s what I think moves things like brand, SOPs, and data from being “administrative help” or “bureaucracy” into systems that support daily operations – matching intent and decisions made with how the work gets done – and gets (and keeps!) everything aligned with what you’re working to achieve.

To tie this all back to where this article started: The way I employ coaching and advisory are probably where that sense of “you’re the best coach I’ve ever had – even though you don’t call yourself a coach” actually comes from. (And, honestly, I don’t care what label you use as long as we’re making progress together.)

Some Questions to Answer (or not)

What’s one thing on your plate right now that you could use some help with?

What’s the shape of that problem – and what’s the primary type of support you need? Is it coaching, consulting, advisory, or some mix?

You don’t necessarily have to know what you need. A good service provider should be able to help you identify the mix during their discovery process. That discovery process is also your chance to vet them – sales is a two-way street.

Barbara Olsafsky